Path: vixen.cso.uiuc.edu!news.sprintlink.net!news-peer.sprintlink.net!uunet!bounce-back
From: Jani Patokallio <jpatokal@alpha.hut.fi>
Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,news.admin.censorship,news.admin.hierarchies,news.admin.net-abuse.announce,news.admin.net-abuse.misc
Subject: RESULT: news.admin.net-abuse reorganization all groups pass
Supersedes: <846418455.28217@uunet.uu.net>
Followup-To: news.groups
Date: 9 Nov 1996 09:46:12 -0500
Organization: Usenet Volunteer Votetakers
Lines: 847
Sender: tale@uunet.uu.net
Approved: newgroups-request@uunet.uu.net
Message-ID: <847550753.7941@uunet.uu.net>
Reply-To: jpatokal@alpha.hut.fi
NNTP-Posting-Host: rodan.uu.net
Archive-Name: news.admin.net-abuse-reorg
Xref: vixen.cso.uiuc.edu news.announce.newgroups:9008 news.admin.censorship:22856 news.admin.hierarchies:1250
RESULT
moderated group news.admin.announce (renames news.admin.net-abuse.announce) passes 443:32
unmoderated group news.admin.net-abuse.email passes 451:28
moderated group news.admin.net-abuse.policy passes 441:36
moderated group news.admin.net-abuse.bulletins passes 448:34
moderated group news.admin.net-abuse.sightings passes 434:40
unmoderated group news.admin.net-abuse.usenet passes 447:32
news.admin.net-abuse reorganization results - 486 valid votes
Yes No : 2/3? >100? : Pass? : Group
---- ---- : ---- ----- : ----- : -------------------------------------------
443 32 : Yes Yes : Yes : news.admin.announce
451 28 : Yes Yes : Yes : news.admin.net-abuse.email
441 36 : Yes Yes : Yes : news.admin.net-abuse.policy
448 34 : Yes Yes : Yes : news.admin.net-abuse.bulletins
434 40 : Yes Yes : Yes : news.admin.net-abuse.sightings
447 32 : Yes Yes : Yes : news.admin.net-abuse.usenet
Newsgroups lines:
news.admin.announce Announcements for news adminstrators. (Moderated)
news.admin.net-abuse.bulletins Bulletins of action about net abuse. (Moderated)
news.admin.net-abuse.email Discussion of abuse of email systems.
news.admin.net-abuse.policy Discussion of net abuse policy. (Moderated)
news.admin.net-abuse.sightings Sightings of net abuse. (Moderated)
news.admin.net-abuse.usenet Discussion of abuse of the Usenet system.
The voting period closed at 23:59:59 UTC, 7 Nov 1996.
This vote was conducted by a neutral third party. Questions
about the proposed group should be directed to the proponent.
Proponent: Tim Skirvin <tskirvin@uiuc.edu>
Votetaker: Jani Patokallio <jpatokal@alpha.hut.fi>
RATIONALE: all groups
The topic of net-abuse is a pressing issue on Usenet today. Currently,
there are two major groups for discussion of the topic: news.admin.
net-abuse.announce, a moderated forum for announcements about net abuse,
and news.admin.net-abuse.misc, a group for everything else.
Unfortunately, each of these groups suffer from their problems. news.
admin.net-abuse.announce brings in fairly high traffic for a moderated
group (oftentimes upwards of 20-30 per day), mostly consisting of
reports of action taken against net abuse. However, this group is also
used for important announcements, of general interest to all news
administrators. Because of its high traffic levels, however, most
administrators are unable to follow the group.
News.admin.net-abuse.misc, on the other hand, is an unmoderated forum.
As a result of this, it is very high traffic - usually upwards of
several hundred messages per day, with a goodly portion of them
crossposted among many unrelated or only vaguely-related groups. The
traffic has gotten high enough to make it difficult to follow the group
for those that wish to learn about and discuss net abuse.
This proposal would help solve all of the major problems of the news.
admin.net-abuse hierarchy. First of all, news.admin.net-abuse.announce
would be split into two groups: news.admin.net-abuse.bulletins, a moderated
group for the reports of action that make up the bulk of the current
group, and news.admin.announce, a moderated, low-traffic replacement for
news.admin.net-abuse.announce that would be of interest to all news
administrators.
Secondly, the problems of news.admin.net-abuse.misc would be alleviated
by the creation of four supplemental groups in the news.admin.net-abuse
hierarchy: news.admin.net-abuse.email, for discussion of email abuse,
news.admin.net-abuse.sightings, a robomoderated forum for users to
announce sightings of net abuse, news.admin.net-abuse.usenet, for
discussion of Usenet abuse, and news.admin.net-abuse.policy, a robo-
moderated forum for discussion of policies regarding net abuse that
disallows crossposts. The additional groups will allow users to read
messages only on those topics that they are interested in.
Several automated tools will be used to help manage the groups. Most
moderation will take place through auto-moderation bots; all groups will
be watched over by "Dave the Resurrector", a program that automatically
reposts cancelled messages. Other tools may also be used as circumstances
require and technology allows.
CHARTER: all groups
The news.admin.net-abuse.* hierarchy is for discussion of abuse of Usenet
and/or the Internet; it is not for discussion of abuse of groups or
indiviuals on such networks, such as flames, personal attacks, or off-
topic messages.
Binaries are specifically prohibited from all groups in the news.admin.*
hierarchy, except as examples of other abuse. All messages removed by
unauthorized cancels in the hierarchy will be automaticly reposted by
Dave the Resurrector or a similar program, at the discretion of the
group moderator or, for the unmoderated groups, the operator of the
resurrector program. Spams, gateway spews, and other attacks on the
system itself will be removed as appropriate, following standard Usenet
guidelines.
END CHARTER.
CHARTER: news.admin.announce
News.admin.announce is a forum for important announcements for news
administrators. It is a moderated forum, watched over by a team
of moderators for added speed. Possible topics for messages include
announcements regarding news transport or browsing software, Frequently
Asked Questions lists, announcements of new EMP cancellers, announcements
of new cancellation criteria, reports that directly relate to the future
of Usenet, reports on legal issues that directly affect news
administrators such as the Communications Decency Act, and so forth.
News.admin.announce is moderated by a team of moderators. The moderators
will approve any message that they feel fits the following criteria:
1. The message is an announcement that the moderators feel is important
for most or all news administrators.
2. The message is formatted for 78 or less characters per line, and
is easily human readable.
3. The message is not a binary, nor will it break standard Usenet
readers.
4. Followups for the message are set appropriately.
Unapproved posts will be cancelled. At any time, moderators can be added
or removed by a majority vote of the then-current moderators.
END CHARTER.
MODERATOR INFO: news.admin.announce
Moderator: Dave Barr <barr@math.psu.edu>
Moderator: Abby Franquemont-Guillory <abbyfg@tezcat.net>
Administrative contact address: news-admin-announce-request@math.psu.edu
Article submission address: news-admin-announce@math.psu.edu
END MODERATOR INFO.
CHARTER: news.admin.net-abuse.email
News.admin.net-abuse.email is a forum for discussion of possible abuses
of e-mail. Possible topics include mailbombing, denial-of-service attacks,
"listserv bombs", unsolicited and/or unwanted mail, email address lists,
mailing list abuse, large-scale mailings in general, chain letters, "email
viruses" such as Good Times, filtering software such as procmail, and so
forth. Flames and other personal attacks received through email are not
on-topic, unless they are related to another form of abuse.
News.admin.net-abuse.email is unmoderated.
END CHARTER.
CHARTER: news.admin.net-abuse.misc
News.admin.net-abuse.misc is a forum for discussion of possible net
abuse not covered by the rest of the news.admin.net-abuse.* hiearchy.
Possible topics include ping-storming, site aliasing, denial of service
attacks, and anything else that does not fit into the other forums in the
news.admin.net-abuse.* hierarchy.
News.admin.net-abuse.misc is unmoderated.
END CHARTER.
CHARTER: news.admin.net-abuse.policy
News.admin.net-abuse.policy is a moderated forum for discussion of
policy and site-management issues related to net abuse. Possible topics
include Acceptable Use Policies, what actions should be taken against
abusers, discussion of third-party cancel messages, possible actions against
abusive sites such as rogue site declarations, discussion of what is and
is not net abuse, and so forth.
News.admin.net-abuse.policy is a moderated forum. The robomoderator of
the group will disallow any and all crossposted messages, message spews,
binary messages, and any possible attacks on the group as required. Dave
the Resurrector (or a similar program) will be run on the group, forged
approvals will be automatically cancelled, and other programs may be used
as circumstances require.
News.admin.net-abuse.policy is moderated by a robot moderator, run by a
team of operators. The robot will automatically approve and post messages
that:
1. Are not crossposted.
2. Contain only text formatted for <78 columns, excepting quoted material.
3. Cannot be determined to directly violate the charter of the group by
the robot moderator alone (for which the criterion will be published.)
Messages not approved by the robot moderator will be sent back to the
sender with a copy of the charter, though at most one copy of the
information will be sent per week. Changes to the robot moderator
can only be enacted by a majority vote of the then-current operators;
similarly, operators can be added or removed by a majority vote of the
then-current operators.
END CHARTER.
MODERATOR INFO: news.admin.net-abuse.policy
Moderator: Scott Forbes <forbes@ravenna.com>
Moderator: Tim Skirvin <tskirvin@uiuc.edu>
Administrative contact address: nanap-req@ravenna.com
Article submission address: nanap-sub@ravenna.com
END MODERATOR INFO.
CHARTER: news.admin.net-abuse.bulletins
News.admin.net-abuse.bulletins is a moderated forum for bulletins of action
taken against net abuse. Appropriate subjects include cancellation
notices (EMP/ECP, spew, binary, and others), status reports from individual
systems concerning action taken against abusers, results of tracking
campaigns, "rogue site" declarations, and the like.
News.admin.net-abuse.bulletins is moderated by a team of moderators.
Followups will be set to the appropriate news.admin.net-abuse.* groups.
Dave the Resurrector (or a similar program) will be run on the group,
forged approvals will be automatically cancelled, and other programs
may be run at the discretion of the moderators.
The moderators will approve messages based on the following criteria:
1. The message is a report of actions taken relating to and against
net abuse.
2. The message is formatted for 78 or less characters per line, and
is easily human readable.
3. The message is not determined to directly violate the charter of the
group.
The moderators may auto-approve posts from certain individuals, at their
own discretion.
At any time, moderators can be added or removed by a majority vote of
the then-current moderators. Messages with forged Approval: lines not
approved by the moderators will be cancelled.
END CHARTER.
MODERATOR INFO: news.admin.net-abuse.bulletins
Moderator: Dave Barr <barr@math.psu.edu>
Moderator: Paul Phillips <paulp@cerf.net>
Moderator: Joel Furr <jfurr@acpub.duke.edu>
Administrative contact address: news-admin-bulletins-request@math.psu.edu
Article submission address: news-admin-bulletins@math.psu.edu
END MODERATOR INFO.
CHARTER: news.admin.net-abuse.sightings
News.admin.net-abuse.sightings is a forum for reports of sightings of
net abuse. It is a robomoderated forum, allowing only properly
formatted posts. Followups are required to be set strictly out of the
group and into the appropriate group in the news.admin.net-abuse.*
hierachy.
News.admin.net-abuse.sightings is moderated by a robot moderator, run
by a team of operators. The robot will automatically approve and post
messages according to the following criteria:
1. The message is formatted for 78 or less characters per line, and
is easily human readable.
2. The message follows a publicized template specified by the operator
of the robot moderator. For example, the following format -may- be
the standard for a Usenet abuse sighting:
--
(headers)
Subject: [usenet] (Standard Subject)
Followup-to: news.admin.net-abuse.usenet
From: (valid address) -or- Reply-to: (valid address)
(other standard headers)
(body)
Abuse-spotted-in: (first group spotted)
Abuse-Subject: (subject from abuse)
Type-of-abuse: (EMP, ECP, binary, forgery, etc. No set rules here)
Description: (description and/or comments)
-
(Full headers of the abuse)
(Full body of the abuse)
--
Messages may be automatically reformatted by the robot moderator for
archival and standardization purposes, using procedures established by
the operator of the robot moderator. For example, the following changes
may be made, if deemed appropriate:
1. Only the first fifteen lines of the body of the abuse may be
posted; the rest would be archived, but not posted.
2. The abuse may be reformatted to fit into 78 columns.
3. If the text of the abuse would cause technical problems with some
newsreaders, the problem text may be replaced with X's; if the abuse
would cause problems with most newsreaders, the article may not be
posted at all.
4. Several headers may be added at the discretion of the operator of the
robot moderator, such as the following:
a. X-Apparently-Complain-To: <postmaster@apparent.site.of.abuse>
b. X-Archive-Number: (a unique number)
c. X-Archives: (URL of site containing group archives)
Messages that do not meet these criteria will be sent back to the sender
with a copy of this charter and a listing of the published templates,
though at most one copy of this information will be sent out per week.
Forged approvals will be automatically cancelled. Changes to the robot
moderator can only be enacted by a majority vote of the then-current
operators; similarly, operators can be added or removed by a majority
vote of the then-current operators.
END CHARTER.
MODERATOR INFO: news.admin.net-abuse.sightings
Moderator: "J.D. Falk" <jdfalk@cybernothing.org>
Moderator: Tim Skirvin <tskirvin@uiuc.edu>
Administrative contact address: nanas-req@cybernothing.org
Article submission address: nanas-sub@cybernothing.org
END MODERATOR INFO.
CHARTER: news.admin.net-abuse.usenet
News.admin.net-abuse.usenet is a forum for discussion of possible abuses
of Usenet (as defined in news.announce.newusers). Possible topics include
spamming or Excessive Multi-Posting (EMP), Excessive Cross-Posting (ECP),
Usenet chain letters such as MAKE.MONEY.FAST, forged or third-party
cancellations, broken Usenet gateways, forgery of another user, forged
approvals in moderated groups, massively crossposted "flametrolls", abuse
of the newsgroup creation system, general purpose netiquette, and so forth.
News.admin.net-abuse.usenet is unmoderated.
END CHARTER.
news.admin.net-abuse reorganization Final Vote Ack
news.admin.net-abuse.usenet --------+
news.admin.net-abuse.sightings -------+|
news.admin.net-abuse.bulletins ------+||
news.admin.net-abuse.policy -----+|||
news.admin.net-abuse.email ----+||||
news.admin.announce ---+|||||
||||||
101751.3442@compuserve.com Dave Mayall YYYYYY
2hpwolf@cyberdrive.net Paul S. Wolf YYYYYY
abbyfg@tezcat.net Abby Franquemont-Guillory YYYYYY
abostick@netcom.com Alan Bostick YYYYYY
abraham@dina.kvl.dk Per Abrahamsen YYYY-Y
adia@egnatia.ee.auth.gr Alejandros Diamandidis Y-YY-Y
al442@freenet.carleton.ca Derek Tam YYYYYY
Alain.Deckers@nessie.mcc.ac.uk Alain Deckers YYYYYY
alan@papaioea.manawatu.gen.nz Alan Brown YYYYYY
alansz@mellers1.psych.berkeley.edu Alan Schwartz -YYYYY
amergyn@ix.netcom.com John A. Osborne YYYYYY
an448@freenet.carleton.ca Yves Bellefeuille NNYNNY
anandc@ugcs.caltech.edu Anand Chelian YYYYYY
andrewg@microlise.co.uk Andrew Gierth YYYYYY
andrewv@io.org Andrew Vendryes YYYYYY
andyl@harlequin.com Andy Latto YYYYYY
ARCLGS@langate.gsu.edu Leo Simonetta YYYYYY
arielle@taronga.com Stephanie da Silva YYYYYY
atari@freemark.com Rich Tietjens YYYYYY
attrembley@mke5.ra.rockwell.com Trembley, Andrew T (2-0131) YYYYYY
awhite@c031.aone.net.au Anthony White -YYYYY
awouk@nilenet.com Arthur Wouk YYYYYY
Bachem@rrz.uni-koeln.de Jens Chr. Bachem YYYYYY
barr@math.psu.edu David Barr YYYYYY
bdp@millcomm.com Brian Peterson YYYYYY
bds@ipp-garching.mpg.de Bruce Scott YYYYYY
bearhair@ripco.com Lora D. Kirk YYYYYY
bedmonds@cs.ubc.ca Brian Edmonds YYYYYY
beitz@benson.nosc.mil Kirk Beitz NNNNNN
bengtl@maths.lth.se Bengt Larsson YNNYNN
betsys@terminus.cs.umb.edu Elizabeth Schwartz YYYYYY
bi518@yfn.ysu.edu Janet Kegg YYYYYY
bieksza@aplcomm.jhuapl.edu David S. Bieksza YYYYYY
bill@scconsult.com Bill Stewart-Cole YYYYYY
billones@primenet.com Jeremy Billones YYYYYY
bjv@herbison.com B.J. Herbison -YYYYY
bly@star.rl.ac.uk Martin Bly YYYYYY
bo@plea.se Bo Bjulen YYYYYY
boby@pixi.com Robert A. Yetman YYYYYY
bonine@huitzilo.tezcat.com Steve Bonine YYYYYY
bonomi@delta.ece.nwu.edu Robert Bonomi YYYYYY
booda@datasync.com Martin H. Booda NNNNNN
bouillon@cs.uni-sb.de Peter G. Bouillon YYYYYY
bouvin@daimi.aau.dk Niels Olof Bouvin YYYYYY
boveer@CLI.DI.Unipi.IT Bove Luca YYYYYY
bparker@interaccess.com Ben Parker YYYYYY
brennan@watsun.cc.columbia.edu Joseph Brennan YYYYYY
brian@esd.nsc.com Brian Marley YYYYYY
bromage@silas.cc.monash.edu.au David Bromage YYYYYY
bruce@kenosis.com Bruce Baugh YYYYYY
BSCHLESINGER@nssdca.gsfc.nasa.gov Barry M. Schlesinger -YYYNY
bserviss@nr.infi.net B Serviss YYYYYY
buglady@bronze.lcs.mit.edu Aliza R. Panitz YYYYYY
bumvan@infi.net Lee S. Bumgarner YYYYYY
burley@astro.ubc.ca Greg Burley YYYYYY
c28f62@world.std.com Mark Kramer NNNNNN
camilee@gnn.com Lee Grant YYYYYY
cassaign@clipper.ens.fr Julien Cassaigne YYYYYY
cbrand@ccgate.hac.com Chris Brand YYYYYY
ccp2@csd.uwm.edu Chris Parks YYYYYY
ccs95@aber.ac.uk Christian Alice Scarborough YYYYYY
chenn@utkux.utcc.utk.edu Nelson Chen NYYYYY
chl@clw.cs.man.ac.uk Charles Lindsey YYYYYY
chpr@via.at Christian Pree YYYYYY
chris.lewis.0900639@bnr.ca Chris Lewis YYYYYY
chris.smith@zymark.com Chris Smith YYYYYY
ChrisC@pobox.co.uk Chris Clough YYYYYY
christij@unix.asb.com Joseph Christie YYYYYY
churchyh@ccwf.cc.utexas.edu Henry Churchyard YYYYYY
CJIM@OCAXP0.CC.OBERLIN.EDU Jim Anderson YYYYYY
ckk@pobox.com Chris Koenigsberg YYYYYY
cks@hawkwind.utcs.toronto.edu Chris Siebenmann YYYYYY
claycamp@southwind.net Ryan Claycamp YYYYYY
coleman@leland.Stanford.EDU Michele Coleman YYYYYY
corwyn@chesco.com John Crothers YYYYYY
crleech@freenet.carleton.ca Colin Leech YYYYYY
crn@netix.demon.co.uk Chris Newport YYYYYY
croyle@serv2.fwi.com Don Croyle YYYYYY
cuniacke@ford.com C. Jeremy Uniacke YYYYYY
cwestbury@intranet.com Christopher G. Westbury YYYYYY
d1dd@dtek.chalmers.se Daniel Deimert YYYYYY
d90-two@nada.kth.se Thomas Wolmer YYYYYY
daly@ppd.Kodak.COM Matthew Daly YYYYYY
damouth@eecs.umich.edu Daniel Damouth YYYYYY
daniel.rybowski@infoboard.be Daniel Rybowski YYYYYY
daniel@vis.inf.ethz.ch Daniel Gerald Kluge YYYYYY
danm@interlog.com Dan McKinnon YYYYYY
danno@chsw.com Daniel A. Norton Y-----
dan_moore@supra.com Daniel L. Moore YYYYYY
dave@frackit.com Dave Ratcliffe YYYYYY
dave@kachina.jetcafe.org Dave Hayes NNNNNN
dave@stejonda.demon.co.uk Dave JW Day YYYYYY
david@dclf.demon.co.uk David CL Francis -YYYYY
david@wood2.demon.co.uk David Wood YYYYYY
davidg@netcom.com David Guntner YYYYYY
davidsen@tmr.com Bill Davidsen YYYYYY
dbowie@sas.upenn.edu David Bowie Y-YY--
dc@panix.com David W. Crawford YYYYYY
dcook@maths.adelaide.edu.au David Cook YYYYYY
debraw@wwa.com Debra Walker YYYYYY
deepak.brar@macsch.com Deepak Brar YYNNNY
denebeim@deepthot.cary.nc.us Jay Denebeim YYYYYY
dennis_goos@mindlink.net Mally YYYYYY
dformosa@st.nepean.uws.edu.au David Formosa YYYYYY
dfox@belvdere.vip.best.com David E. Fox YYYYYY
dhartung@mcs.com Dan Hartung YYYYYY
dhathaw@cris.com David D. Hathaway -Y----
djr98665@tree.egr.uh.edu David Robertson YYYYYY
dkelsey@cas.org Dan Kelsey YYYYYY
dloebell@nimbus.ocis.temple.edu David Loebell YYYYYY
dlrowell@concentric.net David L. Rowell YYYYYY
dmrovner@students.wisc.edu Dorothea M. Rovner YYYYYY
dnelson@emsphone.com Dan Nelson YYYYYY
dobson@info.usuhs.mil Michael E. Dobson YYYYYY
doloresn@d-and-d.com Dolores Nichols YYYYYY
donfnord+@pitt.edu Don Fnordlioni YYYYYY
donkiely@polarnet.com Don Kiely YYYYYY
dosborne@ix.netcom.com Diana Osborne YYYYYY
doug@bullet.towson.edu Doug McNaught YYYYYY
dpf@ihug.co.nz David Farrar YYYYYY
dragonsl@scn.org Ralph lindberg YYYYYY
drisner@mail.swlaw.edu David Risner YY-YYY
dshaw@cs.jhu.edu David Shaw YYYYYY
dubach1@husc.harvard.edu Joev Dubach YYYYYY
dunnk@dsmo.com Kristen M. Dunn YYYYYY
dwarren@NetUSA.Net Douglas Warren YYYYYY
dwd@ra.snu.ac.kr SeokChan Lee YYYNNY
dzeiger@netcom.com David Zeiger YYYYYY
e93_bea@elixir.e.kth.se BENGT ÅLLEBRAND YYYYYY
earl.foster@boeing.com Earl Foster YYYYYY
eb70@dial.pipex.com Francis Breame YYYYYY
ebeatty@ibm.net Edward Beatty YYYYYY
ebehr@internode.net Eve M. Behr YYYYYY
eguy@mindspring.com Eric Guy YYYYYY
eholmes@onramp.net Ellen Holmes YYYYYY
EKNUTH@tiny.computing.csbsju.edu Elizabeth T. Knuth NYYNNN
eli@NetUSA.Net Elijah Griffin YYYYYY
ellerbe@his.com P Ellerbe YYYYYY
ellis@corinth.alphalink.com Rick Ellis YYYYYY
eric@sonic.net Eric Eisenhart YYYYYY
eric@winternet.com Eric L. Pederson YYYYYY
eridani@ix.netcom.com Belinda Bryan YYYYYY
erik@pond.com Erik Schultz YYYYYY
Espen.Ore@hd.uib.no Espen Ore YYYYYY
essawy@mindspring.com Hussein Essawy YYYYYY
etobfj@eto.ericsson.se Børre Fjeldsø YYYYYY
faigin@solarium.aero.org Daniel P Faigin YYYYYY
farquhar@acsu.buffalo.edu Erik Farquhar YY---Y
ffcat@hotmail.com Fat Freddy's Cat NNNNNN
flodin@eskimo.com Joe Flodin YYYYYY
fluffyc@hotmail.com Fluffy The Cat NNNNNN
fpv@xymph.iaf.nl Frans P. de Vries YYYYYY
fritza@tezcat.com Fritz Anderson YYYYYY
froggy@praline.no.neosoft.com Carlos May YYYYYY
fsandy@sunspot.tiac.net Frank Sandy YYYYYY
g.belanger@ieee.org Gerard L. Belanger YYYYYY
gaillard@panix.com Ed Gaillard YYYYYY
ganymede@vellocet.insync.net Greg R. Broderick YYYYYY
garrapat@ix.netcom.com Richard Allen Faulkner YYYYYY
gautamg@panix.com Gautam Guliani YYYNYY
gazissax@netcom.com Lynn Diana Gazis-Sax YYYYYY
geneh@onix.com Gene N. Haldeman YYYYYY
genie@panix.com Andy Finkenstadt YYYYYY
Gerard@galatham.demon.co.uk Gerard Alan Latham YYYYYY
gerdw@cougar.vut.edu.au David Gerard YYYYYY
gnb@bby.com.au Gregory Bond YYYYYY
goonsquad@hotmail.com Goon Squad NNNNNN
gordy@panix.com Gordy Thompson YYYYYY
gp@mamba.demon.co.uk Gavin Lawson YYYYYY
grabiner@math.berkeley.edu David Grabiner YYYYYY
grandi@mirfak.tuc.noao.edu Steve Grandi YYYYYY
Greg-Lindahl@deshaw.com Greg Lindahl YYYYYY
grendel90@hotmail.com Grendel90 NNNNNN
groppi@hotmail.com Sharon Groppi NNNNNN
guera@juno.com Cheryl Neas YYYYYY
gustavus@iglou.com Steve Gustafson YYYYYY
gwb@n3gb.umd.edu George Baltz YYYYYY
hamilton@alumni.umbc.edu Diana Hamilton YYYYYY
handler@netaxs.com Michael Handler YYYYYY
HaskettP@cc.sdstate.edu Phil Haskett YYYYYY
hayter@ultryx.com Jim Hayter YYYYYY
hbp@pip.dknet.dk Hans B. Petersen YYYYYY
heilmayr@math.berkeley.edu Stephan Heilmayr YYYYYY
hermit@cats.ucsc.edu William R Ward YYYYYY
hgoldste@bbs.mpcs.com Howard Goldstein YYYYYY
hneeman@ncsa.uiuc.edu Henry Neeman YYYYYY
HopeRobert@worldnet.att.net Hope Robert YYYYYY
horsie@ziplink.net Greg Andruk YYYYYY
Ian.Craigen@nz.eds.com Ian Craigen YYYYYY
Ian@rocker.demon.co.uk Ian C. Strachan YYYYYY
ian@slc.axxis.com Ian Leicht YYYYYY
ibell@chass.utoronto.ca Ian Bell YYYYYY
ikluft@thunder.sbay.org Ian Kluft YYYYYY
imurphy@rapidnet.net Ian Murphy YYYYYY
irina@rempt.xs4all.nl Irina Rempt YYYYYY
isaak@figment.aurora.com Mark Isaak YYYY-Y
J.Goldberg@cranfield.ac.uk Jeffrey Goldberg YYYYYY
jaed@best.com Jeanne DeVoto Y-YYY-
jaffo@onramp.net Michael Duff II YYYYYY
jai@aloha.com Jai Maharaj NNNNNN
james@biometry.demon.co.uk James Lynn YYYYYY
jamie@cs.sfu.ca Jamie Andrews YYYYYY
jason@r33h77.res.gatech.edu Jason Bennett YYYYYY
jason@radar.demon.co.uk Jason Faultless -YYY-Y
jay818@concentric.net Jay Lapidus YYYYYY
jbl@levin.mv.com J. B. Levin YYYYYY
jbredeho@deltanet.com John E. Bredehoft YYYYYY
jcederq@primenet.com Jerry Cederquist YYYYYY
jdg@rahul.net John David Galt Y-YYY-
jean@kcco.com Jean Liddle YYYYYY
jeff@delta.com Jeffrey L. Woods NYYYYY
jeffford@csugrad.cs.vt.edu Jeff Ford YYYYYY
JeffLeader@WorldNet.att.net Jeffery J. Leader YYYYYY
jeremy@exit109.com Jeremy Nixon YYYYYY
jfberger@nyx.net Joerg Florian Berger N-NNN-
jferro@ece.cmu.edu Jonathan Ferro YYYYYY
jik@cam.ov.com Jonathan Kamens YYYYYY
Jimrtex@gnn.com Jim Riley YNNYYN
jjd@primenet.com Jim Davis YYYYYY
JKLIMM1073@aol.com John Klimm NYNYNN
jkramer@CS.Princeton.EDU Joshua Kramer YYYYYY
jlowman@netcom.com Jim Lowman YYNYNY
jmanso19@skypoint.com Jim Manson YYYYYY
jmcgarry@uoguelph.ca James McGarry YYYYYY
jmckeon@interserf.net John McKeon NNNNNN
jo@delorges.in-berlin.de Jo Meder YYYYYY
joar@ludd.luth.se Joar Nilsson YYYYYY
joe@decoy.uoregon.edu Joe St Sauver YYNYNY
Joel.Ehrlich@salata.com Joel Ehrlich YYYYYY
jon@etrigan.demon.co.uk Jon Abbott YYYYYY
jonzonk@netcom.com jon letham YYYYYY
josh@pogo.cqs.washington.edu Josh Hayes YYYYYY
jrusling@icon.net Charles J. Rusling YYYYYY
jrw@aracnet.com Joyce Reynolds-Ward YYYYYY
jsi@idiom.com Michael Craft NNNNNN
jsk591@merle.acns.nwu.edu Joshua Kreitzer YYYYYY
julesd@fwb.gulf.net Jules Dubois YYYYYY
jwalz@rsg1.er.usgs.gov Janet Walz Y--YY-
jyoung@luna.cas.usf.edu Jonathan Young YYYYYY
kai@khms.westfalen.de Kai Henningsen YYYYYY
kalmoth@rt66.com Peter Vorobieff YYYYYY
kamins@dogeared.com Scot Kamins YYYYYY
katew@cicero.spc.uchicago.edu Katharine Weizel YY---Y
kbibb@best.com Kenneth Bibb YYYYYY
kchurch@ionet.net Kimberly B. Churchwell YYYYYY
kdv@zip.com.au Ken de Veaux YYYYYY
keithcla@netcom.com Keith Clark YYYYYY
keszler@rrnet.com Scott R. Keszler YYYYYY
kimdv@netcom.com Kim DeVaughn YYYYYY
kimketo@utu.fi Kimmo Ketolainen +358 40 555 5508 YYYYYY
kip@monroe.lib.mi.us Kip DeGraaf YYYYYY
kirshenbaum@hplms26.hpl.hp.com Evan Kirshenbaum YYYYYY
kjones@netrax.net Kenneth Jones YYYYYY
km@salata.com Karen Mintzias YYYYYY
knewkirk@pacifier.com KATHRYN GRAHAM YYYYYY
krs@kampsax.dk Karsten Spang YYYYYY
kvankatw@rosarita.engr.ucdavis.edu Kirk Van Katwyk YYYYYY
kwattles@sas.upenn.edu Kirk Wattles YYYYYY
lache@math.uni-duesseldorf.de Stefan Lache YYYYYY
lamont@ece.utexas.edu Lamont Lucas YYYYYY
leino@cc.helsinki.fi Antti Leino YYYYYY
ler@lerami.lerctr.org Larry Rosenman YYYYYY
lfirrantello@BIX.com Mick Brown YYYYYY
list-votes@dream.hb.north.de Martin Schr"oder YYYYYY
litlnemo@slumberland.com Wendi Dunlap YYYYYY
Little.Boss@physics.mcgill.ca Juan Gallego YYYYYY
llurch@networking.stanford.edu Rich Graves YYYYYY
lofstrom@lava.net Karen Lofstrom YYYYYY
lorrie@mellers1.psych.berkeley.edu Lorrie Wood YYYYYY
LSEAMANS@MU3.MILLERSV.EDU Lynne Seamans YYYYYY
luriep@tiac.net Peter Lurie YYYYYY
M.Veldkamp@fys.ruu.nl Michiel Veldkamp YYYYYY
maage@ee.tut.fi Markus Linnala YYYYYY
mac7@po.CWRU.Edu Michael Chary YYYYYY
mallen@i1.net Mark Allen YYYYYY
mant2401@mach1.wlu.ca Jim Mantle YYYYYY
marc@mnsinc.com Marc Choppin YYYYYY
Mark.Dickman@elmail.co.uk Mark Dickman YYYYYY
mark@cello.gina.calstate.edu Mark Crother YYYYYY
markb@lava.net Mark Boudoin YYYYYY
marquez@pacbell.net Aaron Marquez YYYYYY
martin@plaza.ds.adp.com Martin Golding YYYYYY
matthieu@laas.fr Matthieu Herrb YYYYYY
Matus.Uhlar@tuke.sk Matus Uhlar YYYYYY
mau@beatles.cselt.stet.it Maurizio Codogno YN-Y-N
mbnx@co.intel.com Mike Northam YYYYYY
mcoll@panix.com Matthew J Collins YYYYYY
mda-nanavote@triskele.com Michael D. Adams - No Commercial Email Ple YYYYYY
mdr@CyberRamp.net Michael Rathbun YYYYYY
mef@netaxs.com Michael Fessler YYYYYY
meowbot@hotmail.com Friendly Neighborhood Meowbot NNNNNN
mfarah@puc.cl Miguel Farah F. YYYYYY
mhkohne@moberg.com Michael Kohne YYYYYY
mibu@scrum.muc.de Michael Buchenrieder YYYYYY
Michael.Will@student.uni-tuebingen.de Michael Will YYYYYY
mike@cosy.sbg.ac.at Thomas 'Mike' Michlmayr YYYYYY
mikey@itexas.net William H. Crowe YYYYYY
mikko.levanto@vtt.fi Mikko Levanto YYYYYY
milliken@gore.nsc.com Harry Milliken YYYYYY
mjj@emjay.apana.org.au Matthew Jackson YYYYYY
mjwise@lava.net Michael J. Wise YYYYYY
mk59200@cc.tut.fi Markku Kolkka YYYYYY
mkent@acm.org Mike Kent YYYYYY
mlbruce@hotmail.com Matthew L. Bruce NNNNNN
modemac@sunspot.tiac.net Modemac YYYYYY
mol@df.lth.se Magnus Olsson YYYYYY
moose+@CMU.EDU Esther Filderman YYYYYY
mpaden@emory.edu Matthew L. Paden YYYYYY
msevans@mindspring.com Michael Evans YYYYYY
msmeissn@cip.informatik.uni-erlangen.de Marcus Meissner YYYYYY
msoysal@mistik.express.net Mustafa Soysal MS57 NNNNNN
mtpins@isca.uiowa.edu Michael T Pins YYYYYY
mue@gsf.de Bernhard Muenzer YYYYYY
naddy@mips.pfalz.de Christian Weisgerber YYYYYY
nareid@nvg.unit.no Helge Nareid YYYYYY
nat@nataa.fr.eu.org MAKAREVITCH YYYYYY
nathan@metareality.com Nate Waddoups YYYYYY
neeri@iis.ee.ethz.ch Matthias Neeracher YYYYYY
neil@bitey.com Neil Motteram YYYYYY
neilt@spl.co.za Neil Thompson YYYYYY
nelsonb@aztec.asu.edu Bill Nelson YYYYYY
nick@cimio.co.uk Nick Waterman YYYYYY
nick@inferno.fc.hp.com Nick Ingegneri NYNNNY
nkingham@curie.dialix.com.au Nick Kingham YYYYYY
nmcnelly@bu.edu N.A.F. McNelly YYYYYY
nospam@no.spam.no David Heaton YYYYYY
ntenny@qualcomm.com Nathan Tenny YYYYYY
nucci@cac.psu.edu Jeff Nucciarone YYYYYY
olav@viking.mv.com Olav Nieuwejaar NYNNNY
Old.Salt@worldnet.att.net Michael Subelka YYYYYY
oldrose@srv.net Diane Peel YYYYYY
ollivier.robert@eurocontrol.fr Ollivier Robert YYYYYY
owenc002@gold.tc.umn.edu David Owen-Cruise YYYYYY
paasivir@cc.jyu.fi Risto Paasivirta YYYYYY
pan@syix.com Pan YYYYYY
paris@santra.hut.fi Robert Craig Harman YYYYYY
partl@hp01.boku.ac.at Hubert Partl YYYYYY
patl@lcs.mit.edu Patrick J. LoPresti NNNNNN
Pattyb50@cris.com Patty Bybee YYYYYY
paul@econ.yale.edu Paul McGuire YYYYYY
Paul_Green@vos.stratus.com Paul Green -YYYYY
paxil@cancom.net Trevor Tymchuk YYYYYY
pb10003@cam.ac.uk Paul Bolchover YYYYYY
pbuchy@abo.fi Peter A. Buchy YYYYYY
pcuni@cris.com Paul Cuni YYYYYY
peach@entrenet.com Sandy Harris YYYYYY
pem4958@is.NYU.EDU Petrea Mitchell NNNNNN
pen@iglou.com Pen Helm YYYYYY
per@erix.ericsson.se Per Hedeland YYYYYY
peter@taronga.com Peter da Silva YYYYYY
peterson@ti.com Bob Peterson YYYYYY
pgarcia@image.univ-lyon1.fr Paulo Garcia YYYYYY
Phil.Boswell@codd-date.co.uk Phil Boswell YYYYYY
phil@hedgford.demon.co.uk PHILIP M REYNOLDS YYYYYY
phil@vision25.demon.co.uk Phil Hunt YYYYYY
PHILIP@aleytys.pc.my Philip Chee YYYYYY
phillips@bright.uoregon.edu Chris Phillips YYYYYY
Phil_Calvin@unc.edu Phil Calvin YYYYYY
phredd@mcs.net Blaine Thompson YYNYNY
pjh1@leicester.ac.uk Pete Humble YYYYYY
plittle@strataware.com Peter Littlefield YYYYYY
pmelo@mat.uc.pt Paulo Melo YYYYYY
ppp@pirinen.demon.co.uk Pekka P. Pirinen YYYYYY
pringle@cs.monash.edu.au GLen Pringle YYYYYY
psu08865@odin.cc.pdx.edu Karel Sebek YYYYYY
pw@cacs.usl.edu Pirawat Watanapongse YYYYYY
quirk@swcp.com Taki Kogoma YYYYYY
rahurd@poboxes.com Richard A. Hurd YYYYYY
ralf@ark.franken.de Ralf W. Stephan YYYYYY
ralf@worcester.com Ralph Valentino YYYYYY
rali@meitca.com R A Lichtensteiger YYYYYY
Randell.Jesup@scala.com Randell Jesup YYYYYY
Raphael.Quinet@eed.ericsson.se Raphael Quinet YYYY-Y
raquele@eskimo.com Jonathan Gan YY-YYN
rboerger@sauron.mpd.tandem.com Ron Boerger YNNNNN
rbtalley@postoffice.worldnet.att.net Richard Talley YYYYYY
rbull@facstaff.wisc.edu Rebecca Bull YYYYYY
Redman@cris.com Chad Redman YYYYYY
reid@PSW086.PSI.CH Ivan D Reid YYYYYY
reinaert@.icon.co.za reinaert YYYYYY
rfm@Eng.Sun.COM Rich McAllister YYYYYY
ribwoods@execpc.com Richard B. Woods YYYYYY
rick@bcm.tmc.edu Richard Miller YYYYYY
rjs@isil.lloke.dna.fi Riku Saikkonen YYYYYY
rmcq@figment.as.utexas.edu Rebecca G. McQuitty YYNY-N
rnewman@cybercom.net Ron Newman YYYYYY
rod@ellery.demon.co.uk Rod Ellery YYYYYY
RoehlS@gnn.com Roehl Sybing NNNNNN
ronnie.grant@mogur.com Ronnie Grant YYYYYY
roses@capecod.net Dolores Scaldini YYNNNN
roussin@genesis8.frmug.fr.net EMMANUEL ROUSSIN YYYYYY
roustk@cco.caltech.edu Kevin A Roust YYYYYY
rpluim@xylint.co.uk Robert Pluim YYYYYY
rquinn@sprint.net Robert Quinn YYYYYY
rra@cs.stanford.edu Russ Allbery YYYYYY
rrne@loc.gov RR Neuswanger YYYYYY
rsc@advanced.org R. S. Camm YYYYYY
rucklidg@parc.xerox.com William Rucklidge YYYYYY
russ@seismo.demon.co.uk Russ Evans YYYYYY
rusweber@i-2000.com Russ Weber YYYYYY
rwiegand@i1.net Roger Wiegand YYYYYY
RWPIKUL@science2.watstar.uwaterloo.ca Rick Pikul YYYYYY
sabre@sabri.pc.my S.M.Sabri S.M.Ismail YYYYYY
saken@chardos.connix.com Scott Kenney YYYYYY
Samuel.Stephens.1@uni.massey.ac.nz Sam Stephens YYYYYY
sandee@think.com Daan Sandee YYYYYY
sasha@qv3pluto.LeidenUniv.nl Sasha Semenov -YYYYY
satans.little.helper@worldnet.att.net Jay Breuer YYYYYY
sboddy@freenet.victoria.bc.ca Stewart Boddy YYYYYY
scbyrd@ix.netcom.com Cameron Byrd YYYYYY
scheidell@fdma.fdma.com Michael S. Scheidell YYYYYY
schnarlz@voicenet.com Matthew Schnierle YYYNNY
schow@nortel.ca Stanley Chow YYYYYY
sdavisgl@lawson.appcomp.utas.edu.au Shaun Davis-Gluyas YYYYYY
sekullbe@newscorp.com Scott E. Kullberg YYYYYY
sethb@panix.com Seth Breidbart YYYYYY
sfp@aplcomm.jhuapl.edu Steve Parr YYYYYY
sheryl@seas.gwu.edu Sheryl Coppenger YYYYYY
shettich@octavian.ICS.UCI.EDU Seth Hettich YYYYYY
shrao@nyx.net Shrisha Rao NNNNNN
sillywiz@excession.demon.co.uk Keith M. Lucas YYYYYY
simon@darkmere.gen.nz Simon Lyall YYYYYY
sjanich@mke.ab.com Steve Anich YYYYYY
sjkiii@crl.com Stan Kalisch III YYYYYY
slamb0@worldnet.att.net Sean Lamb -Y-YYY
slk@karpes.stu.rpi.edu Simon Karpen YYYYYY
smatsuda@molbio.med.osaka-u.ac.jp shuji matsuda YYYYYY
smurf@mail.noris.net Matthias Urlichs YYYYYY
sorkin@mcs.net David Sorkin YYYYYY
spmaguir@chat.carleton.ca Sean Maguire YYYYYY
SSG@radixii.com Simon S. Goldenberg YYYYYY
stainles@bga.com Dwight Brown NNNNNN
staloff@hotmail.com Mike Staloff NYNNNN
stefan.kapus@zetnet.co.uk Stefan M Kapusniak YYYYYY
steffent@thorsen.priv.no Steffen Thorsen YYYYYY
sten.drescher@tivoli.com Sten Drescher YYYYYY
Stephan.Neuhaus@dfki.uni-sb.de Stephan Neuhaus YYYYYY
strudeau@babylon5.ultranet.com Scot J. Trudeau -YYYYY
stu@valinor.mythical.com Stu Labovitz NYYYYY
stuart@cosc.canterbury.ac.nz Stuart Yeates YYYYYY
sugarman@world.std.com Steven Garman YYYYYY
surak1@ix.netcom.com Robert C. Jones YYYYYY
sven@loop.com Chris Blanc <sven@loop.com> YYYYNY
swildner@channelz.cologne.de Sascha Wildner YYYYYY
sylvain@ix.netcom.com Nicholas Sylvain YYYYYY
sysuh@kigam.re.kr Sang-yong Suh YYYYYY
tbas@sybase.com Tony Basoglu YYYYYY
tdolby@watson.ibm.com Trevor Dolby YYYYYY
techwiz@cris.com Robert Ritter YYYYYY
theravan@wco.com Ravan Asteris YYYYYY
Thomas.Parmelan@efrei.fr Thomas Parmelan YYYYYY
thomas.womack@merton.oxford.ac.uk Thomas Womack YYYYYY
tjyoung@gwis2.circ.gwu.edu Timothy J. Young YYYYYY
tknab@nyx.net Terry Knab YYYYYY
tlawson@amug.org Todd C. Lawson YYYYYY
tlund@strada.se Tomas Lund YYYYYY
tomed@sprynet.com Thomas O'Rear NNNNNN
tomlogan@loop.com Tom Logan YYYYYY
tomw@rust.net Tom Woodhouse YYYYYY
tprodin@ford.com Timothy Prodin YNYYYN
trog@pathcom.com piranha YYYYYY
truesdell@hotmail.com Charles Truesdell NNNNNY
tskirvin@uiuc.edu Tim Skirvin YYYYYY
turmoil@animal.blarg.net Tim Crowley YYYYYY
twells@netcom.com Tabor J. Wells YYYYYY
uk@ltts.com Udo Klimaschewski YYYYYY
unclmlty@gte.net Uncle Milty YYYYYY
upson@cableol.co.uk Nick Upson YYYYYY
vashti@drmach.demon.co.uk Rachael Munns YYYYYY
vev@michvhf.com Vince Vielhaber YYYYYY
vf@panix.com Victoria C. Fike YYYYYY
vinces@xs4all.nl Vincent Schonau YYYYYY
walt@scott.net walt moffett YYYYYY
wargamer@patriot.net Cheron Fitzgerald YYYYYY
wednsday@huitzilo.tezcat.com Beverley R. White YYYYYY
wgi@aplcomm.jhuapl.edu W. G. Innanen YYYYYY
wolfgang@amadeus.m.eunet.de Wolfgang Keller YYYYYY
wombat@aquilagroup.com Christopher M. Conway YYYYYY
wozz@wookie.net Matt Cable YYYYYY
wrean@cco.caltech.edu Patricia R. Wrean YYYYYY
wrollins@NMSU.Edu William H. Rollins YYYYYY
ws@xivic.ruhr.de Wolfgang Schelongowski YYYYYY
ybmcu@panix.com Ben Yalow YYYYYY
yorick@ic.net Steven Arlow YYYYYY
yurik@nazaroff.msk.ru Yurik V. Nazaroff YYYYYY
zot@ampersand.com Mark Atwood YYYYYY
Votes in error
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
dynamics@scott.skidmore.edu Chris
! No vote statement in message
jlowther@pwa.acusd.edu John Lowther
! No vote statement in message
norska@access.digex.net NorskaWood
! No vote statement in message
root@mailgate1.telekom.de Joerg Maass
! Invalid address
tup@cyberspace.com Charles H. Tupper
! No vote statement in message
--
Jani Patokallio <jpatokal@alpha.hut.fi>
Voting address: <voting@hut.fi>